Meetings ▸ Minutes
Public Utilities and Public Works Committee — Minutes, Oct 30, 2024
City of Somerville, Massachusetts
City Council Public Utilities and Public
Works Committee
Meeting Minutes
6:00 PM
Wednesday, October 30, 2024
The meeting took place remotely via Zoom and was called to order at 6:00 PM by Chair Clingan and
adjourned at 8:05 PM on a roll call vote of 3 in favor (Councilors Strezo, McLaughlin and Clingan),
none against and none absent.
Others present:
Nick Antanavica – Director of Inspectional Services, Kimberly Hutter – Legislative Liaison, Peter
Forcellese – Legislative Clerk.
.
Roll Call
Ward Four City Councilor Jesse Clingan, Ward One City
Councilor Matthew McLaughlin and City Councilor At
Large Kristen Strezo
Present:
1.
Approval of the Minutes of the Public Utilities and Public Works
Committee Meeting of March 18, 2024.
Committee
Minutes
(ID # 24-0403)
ACCEPTED
RESULT:
Ward Four City Councilor Clingan, Ward One City
Councilor McLaughlin and City Councilor At Large Strezo
AYE:
Public Hearing
2.
76 registered voters submitting a petition for a public hearing on the
Somerville Internet Task Force 2019 Report and a Feasibility Study on
Municipal Broadband, pursuant to Section 8 of the City Charter.
Public
Communication
(ID # 24-1088)
Prior to the public hearing, Chair Clingan sponsored Kate Zebrose from the
Somerville Internet Task Force (ITF) to present an overview of the ITF
Executive Summary. She described internet access’ critical role for people
around the world. Policy concerns also shape public opinion about internet
access and the filtering of content by private companies contribute to those
concerns. Competition between 2 cable providers is not sufficient to
significantly improve broadband services. Chair Clingan also sponsored
Cambridge resident Roy Russell, from Upgrade Cambridge, to speak. Mr.
Russell stated that Cambridge has a single internet provider, Comcast.
Cambridge hired a consultant to perform a feasibility study for municipal
broadband and the conclusion was that municipal broadband was feasible
for Cambridge. Mr. Russell noted that there are hundreds of examples of
municipal broadband throughout the United States, with most being
successful. The consultant’s report also noted that the City of Cambridge
Page 1 of 8
Public Utilities and Public Works Committee
Meeting Minutes
October 30, 2024
might have to invest $150 million in order to attract private partners, who
would invest another $4 million and provide service and maintenance for the
next 25 years.
The public hearing was opened. Greg Hill read a statement from Jeffrey
Raits, a member of the ITF, listing the benefits of municipal broadband and
the lack of follow up action by the city. Susan Eldridge stated her support
for municipal broadband as a way to level the playing field. She noted that
it would be expensive for the city but would also allow for the addition of
new technology as it becomes available. Mr. Hill spoke again about the
benefits of municipal broadband and asked that the mayor put out an RFP
for a feasibility study. The public hearing was closed.
Liaison Hutter stated that the Administration realizes that internet access is a
vital resource and said that city staff is committed to working on feasible
solutions and encourages residents to stay engaged with the city and its
digital staff. Councilor Strezo expressed her support but is unsure how to
make it a reality. Through the Chair, she asked a prior speaker, Roy Russell,
how Somerville compares to other communities that have municipal
broadband with regard to population, program cost and density. Mr. Russell
had already left the meeting, however another prior speaker, Greg Hill,
stated that he would provide Councilor Strezo with Mr. Russell’s email
address so that she might pose the question to him.
RECOMMENDED TO BE MARKED WORK
COMPLETED
RESULT:
Grant of Location
3.
Eversource applying for a Grant of Location to install a new hip guy and
anchor at Utility Pole 291/11 in Prospect Street.
Grant of Location
(ID # 24-1240)
This item was withdrawn by Eversource.
RECOMMENDED TO BE WITHDRAWN
RESULT:
Traffic and Parking
4.
By Councilor McLaughlin
That the Director of Parking install a NO THROUGH STREET sign on
Alston Street by the Cross Street intersection.
Order
(ID # 24-1421)
Liaison Hutter had a conversation with the Director of Parking and reported
that the requested sign cannot be installed since the street is, in fact, a
through street.
RECOMMENDED TO BE MARKED WORK
COMPLETED
RESULT:
Page 2 of 8
Public Utilities and Public Works Committee
Meeting Minutes
October 30, 2024
5.
By Councilor McLaughlin
That the Director of Parking enforce parking permit laws on Alston Street.
Order
(ID # 24-1426)
Liaison Hutter stated that PCO’s will enforce the laws while on their routes.
RECOMMENDED TO BE MARKED WORK
COMPLETED
RESULT:
Mobility
6.
By Councilor McLaughlin
That the Director of Mobility prioritize Alston Street for a potential
Neighborways project.
Order
(ID # 24-1425)
Liaison Hutter told the committee that staff will take this item under
advisement, adding that it’s unlikely to be prioritized at this time.
RECOMMENDED TO BE MARKED WORK
COMPLETED
RESULT:
7.
By Councilor McLaughlin
That the Director of Mobility place a sided bump on Alston Street.
Order
(ID # 24-1424)
Liaison Hutter told the committee that this request has been added to the
speed bump list and that a commitment to a timeline cannot be made at this
time.
RECOMMENDED TO BE MARKED WORK
COMPLETED
RESULT:
ISD
8.
By Councilor Clingan
That the Director of Inspectional Services inspect any exterior finishing
down to the wood to ensure there is no asbestos shingling present before
granting building permits.
Order
(ID # 24-1203)
Chair Clingan noted some instances where potential problems may exist and
asked if there is a way to inspect properties in a more in depth manner to
prevent asbestos from being disposed of improperly. Director Antanavica
noted that there has been an increase in complaints, possibly due in part to a
lack of education. He went on to say that it’s not feasible to check every
building, so steps have been taken to have inspectors obtain asbestos
certifications which will allow them to know what is supposed to happen
with respect to asbestos removal and to determine if the removal was done
properly. This will help ISD to identify problems, going forward. The
Director noted that OSHA compliant safety plans must be in place and that
both a general contractor designee and a safety officer must be on site.
Page 3 of 8
Public Utilities and Public Works Committee
Meeting Minutes
October 30, 2024
RECOMMENDED TO BE MARKED WORK
COMPLETED
RESULT:
9.
By Councilor McLaughlin
That the Director of Inspectional Services inspect open space parcels along
McGrath Highway, behind Alston Street and Chester Avenue for rodent
activity and bait accordingly.
Order
(ID # 24-1419)
Director Antanavica said that Director Ziegler was at the site earlier in the
week and that now, the ownership of the property needs to be determined.
ISD will try to coordinate with the state to resolve that issue. Councilor
McLaughlin requested that any findings be forwarded to the committee.
RECOMMENDED TO BE MARKED WORK
COMPLETED
RESULT:
10.
By Councilor McLaughlin
That the Director of Inspectional Services address graffiti on Alston Street
and ensure the property owners are maintaining their properties.
Order
(ID # 24-1423)
Director Antanavica stated that citation letters have been sent.
RECOMMENDED TO BE MARKED WORK
COMPLETED
RESULT:
11.
By Councilor Mbah
That the Director of Inspectional Services and the Commissioner of Public
Works appear before this Council to discuss the problems of local
restaurants complying with the requirements of proper waste handling and
contracting for city waste collection.
Order
(ID # 24-1272)
Director Antanavica commented that ISD is looking at revising and
innovating ways to get compliance from restaurants as well as considering a
revamping of the food licensing process. He noted that there is a dedicated
dumpster inspector but said that he could not speak to waste collection being
performed by the city, as this is a DPW matter, but he did state that there are
some legacy restaurants that are still having their waste removed by the city.
RECOMMENDED TO BE MARKED WORK
COMPLETED
RESULT:
Tree Warden
12.
By Councilor McLaughlin
That the Tree Warden inspect the trees behind Chester Avenue and address
falling limbs.
Order
(ID # 24-1422)
Liaison Hutter said that since this is private property, it’s not practice for the
city to inspect the trees. Councilor McLaughlin noted that the city had
Page 4 of 8
Public Utilities and Public Works Committee
Meeting Minutes
October 30, 2024
addressed this in the past and that he’s not comfortable leaving dangerous
trees unattended. Director Antanavica said that this will be added to the
frequent property list and explained that ISD would need to update the
property’s track record on ticketing in order to proceed to taking court
action. If the tree warden deems that the situation presents an imminent
danger, then more options are available to the city..
RECOMMENDED TO BE MARKED WORK
COMPLETED
RESULT:
DPW
13.
By Councilor McLaughlin
That the Commissioner of Public Works clean the open space parcels along
McGrath Highway, behind Alston Street and Chester Avenue of trash and
debris.
Order
(ID # 24-1420)
RECOMMENDED TO BE MARKED WORK
COMPLETED
RESULT:
14.
By Councilor Clingan and Councilor Strezo
That the Commissioner of Public Works create a process for residents to
report downed and dangling utility lines.
Order
(ID # 24-1202)
Chair Clingan stated that he wants this to be a simple process and noted that
there is an ordinance in place. He believes that there are some city staff who
know which utilities own the poles throughout the city and he noted that
each utility company has a liaison to deal with issues in the city. What he
would like to happen is for the city to contact the appropriate utility
company when a request is submitted to 311, and then note same in the 311
request, rather than having the resident who submitted the request being told
to contact the utility department. Director Antanavica commented that 311
routes the request to the appropriate people if they know who owns the
utility line. Councilor Strezo noted that it’s clear that the utilities are not
taking the city seriously. She asked about getting access to a database of
pole owners and Director Antanavica replied that he doesn’t run that
database, so he can’t make that decision. Chair Clingan stated that the
database is with the Engineering Department and he also noted that another
order should be put in to discuss state law enforcement. Director
Antanavica commented that the city has a delicate relationship with the
utility companies because, at some point, the city may need their help in
another area.
RECOMMENDED TO BE MARKED WORK
COMPLETED
RESULT:
Page 5 of 8
Public Utilities and Public Works Committee
Meeting Minutes
October 30, 2024
15.
By Councilor Clingan
That the Commissioner of Public Works install big belly trash barrels at the
intersection of Meacham and Moreland Streets.
Order
(ID # 24-0977)
Liaison Hutter commented that it’s not in the city’s best interest to situate
the barrels at that location and she asked that she be informed of the
concerns of residents so she can look for other suitable remedies.
RECOMMENDED TO BE MARKED WORK
COMPLETED
RESULT:
16.
By Councilor Strezo
That the Commissioner of Public Works re-install the bench, previously
donated and installed in honor of longstanding Brown School principal
Marilyn Haggerty, on the Brown School grounds.
Order
(ID # 24-0039)
Chair Clingan noted that a memo has been submitted regarding this item and
that the bench has been reinstalled.
RECOMMENDED TO BE MARKED WORK
COMPLETED
RESULT:
Assessor
17.
By Councilor McLaughlin
That the Chief Assessor determine the ownership of open space parcels
along McGrath Highway, behind Alston Street and Chester Avenue to
determining who is responsible for maintenance.
Order
(ID # 24-1418)
Liaison Hutter reported that she had a conversation with staff in the
Assessor’s Office. The two parcels in question are 0 Chester Avenue and 0
Alston Street. The Chester Avenue property is owned by a private group in
Texas. Asked who is responsible for trees on this property, Liaison Hutter
replied that the property owner is responsible, however, the city had
responded to some service calls for them in the past. She noted that she is
not aware of any contact being made with the owner.
The Alston Street property was taken by eminent domain by the state in
1954 to build McGrath Highway and there are no other records showing that
the ownership has changed. It’s not clear who has the title, but it is known
that the city has never owned this property. Liaison Hutter will set up a
meeting with DCR and MADOT to explore who holds the title to determine
responsibility for maintenance of the parcel. There is an available graphic
from the 1950s as well as a document from the state from the time of taking.
Councilor McLaughlin commented that the city needs to get to the bottom of
this matter.
Councilor McLaughlin would like this matter to be completed by the next
City Council meeting and he requested that the deed for state land be
Page 6 of 8
Public Utilities and Public Works Committee
Meeting Minutes
October 30, 2024
provided.
RECOMMENDED TO BE MARKED WORK
COMPLETED
RESULT:
Comms
18.
By Councilor Strezo
That the Director of Communications discuss the communication plan to
address move-in/move-out related discarded furniture, including items left
on sidewalks blocking pedestrian pathways and restricting public way
accessibility.
Order
(ID # 24-1268)
Chair Clingan stated that the city needs to do a better job with this issue.
Liaison Hutter reported that she spoke with staff in the Communication
Department and she described the current outreach efforts and plans going
forward. She noted that handouts are given when parking signs and permits
are picked up and that information is also available on the city’s website
welcome page. There is also a social media push in the spring and fall.
Councilor Strezo commented about possibly issuing fines for violations and
perhaps creating a second hand database or social media presence for
discarded items.
RECOMMENDED TO BE MARKED WORK
COMPLETED
RESULT:
Administration
19.
By Councilor Davis
That the Administration allocate additional resources to proactively clean up
used needles and other potentially hazardous items in Seven Hills Park and
other areas.
Resolution
(ID # 24-1205)
Director Antanavica stated that calls regarding sharps should be directed to
311. He reported that ISD personnel has been trained in the disposal of
sharps and that the daily morning ‘walk arounds’ in the area have been
increased. A reduction in the number of items to be picked up has been
noticed.
RECOMMENDED TO BE MARKED WORK
COMPLETED
RESULT:
20.
By Councilor Wilson and Councilor Scott
That the Administration update this Council on plans for the Cummings
School building and Founders Memorial Skating Rink this fiscal year.
Resolution
(ID # 24-1306)
Liaison Hutter reported that the Cummings will be used as a warming center
and that the city is determining what needs to be done to the facility to make
it ready. A timeline for any needed repairs has not yet been established, but
Liaison Hutter noted that the repairs will allow the building to be used for
Page 7 of 8
Public Utilities and Public Works Committee
Meeting Minutes
October 30, 2024
other uses in the future. The Founders Rink is being used by the Parks and
Recreation Department to provide multi-generational recreation space.
KEPT IN COMMITTEE
RESULT:
Director of Emergency Management
21.
By Councilor Strezo
That the Director of Emergency Management discuss the city’s emergency
response plan for freight train routes and action plans in the event of a
derailment or chemical spill.
Order
(ID # 24-1182)
Chair Clingan noted that a memo has been submitted regarding this item
KEPT IN COMMITTEE
RESULT:
Referenced Documents:
•
PUPW - 2024-10-30 OEM Memo (with 24-1182)
•
PUPW - 2024-10-30 Memo Bench at Brown School (with 24-0039)
•
PUPW - 2024-10-30 Eversource Withdrawal Letter (with 24-1240)
•
PUPW - 2024-10-30 Plan Taking 1954 Shawmut St (with 24-1418)
•
PUPW - 2024-10-30 Relevant Assessors map 0 Alston (with 24-1418)
•
PUPW - 2024-10-30 Taking book8352 page93 1954 Shawmut St (with 24-1418)
Page 8 of 8