Meetings ▸ Minutes
Public Utilities and Public Works Committee — Minutes, Dec 9, 2024
City of Somerville, Massachusetts
City Council Public Utilities and Public
Works Committee
Meeting Minutes
6:00 PM
Monday, December 9, 2024
This meeting was held via Zoom and was called to order by Chair Clingan at 6:02pm and adjourned at
7:28pm with a roll call vote of 3 in favor (Councilors Strezo, McLaughlin, Clingan), none opposed, and
none absent.
Others present: Bill Fisher – Director of Emergency Management, Kimberley Hutter – Legislative
Liason at Intergovernmental Affairs, Brian Postlewaite – Director of Engineering, Demetrios Vidalis –
Director of Water and Sewer, Natasha Frazier – Assistant Clerk of Committees.
Roll Call
Ward Four City Councilor Jesse Clingan, Ward One City
Councilor Matthew McLaughlin and City Councilor At
Large Kristen Strezo
Present:
1.
Approval of the Minutes of the Public Utilities and Public Works
Committee Meeting of October 30, 2024.
Committee
Minutes
(ID # 24-1612)
ACCEPTED
RESULT:
Ward Four City Councilor Clingan, Ward One City
Councilor McLaughlin and City Councilor At Large Strezo
AYE:
2.
By Councilor Scott
That the Director of Water and Sewer appear before this Council to discuss
recent extended outages in Ward 2 and mitigation plans for future work.
Order
(ID # 24-1637)
Director Vidalis provided an overview of recenter water shutdowns in Ward
2. He stated that the shutdown on November 12th was planned and that
notifications went out on November 8th indicating there would be a
shutdown from 9am to 3pm. However, the planned shutdown unexpectedly
became an emergency shutdown when an issue was discovered that needed
extensive repair, and the shutdown was extended until 9:30pm. When this
occurred, a notification was communicated to residents. Among the 17 other
shutdowns in the past fiscal year in Ward 2, none of the other shutdowns
went over the anticipated timeframe. He also noted that a few of the other
previous shutdowns were emergencies.
RECOMMENDED TO BE MARKED WORK
COMPLETED
RESULT:
Page 1 of 5
Public Utilities and Public Works Committee
Meeting Minutes
December 9, 2024
3.
By Councilor Mbah, Councilor McLaughlin, Councilor Burnley Jr.,
Councilor Clingan, Councilor Davis, Councilor Ewen-Campen, Councilor
Pineda Neufeld, Councilor Sait, Councilor Scott, Councilor Strezo and
Councilor Wilson
That the Administration provide this Council with a comprehensive status
update of all Veterans Monuments affected by the construction and
renovations around the High School complex.
Resolution
(ID # 24-1608)
Chair Clingan provided an overview of the memo provided for this agenda
item. He stated that there is concern regarding the condition of the
monuments that are in storage after being removed to allow for construction.
Councilors expressed a desire to see the monument work move forward in
honor of Somerville’s Veterans. Councilor Strezo emphasized the
importance of keeping the community updated about this project and asked
the Administration about the status of her request to place signage where the
monuments were previously located in order to communicate that they will
return. Liaison Hutter stated that she is in conversation with staff about next
steps in the process and that the priority has been keeping the monuments in
their best condition. She stated that she will inquire with staff about the
feasibility and timeline for installing signage.
Councilor McLaughlin stated that the current plan is complicated and
suggested that the City does not wait to resolve other outstanding matters
such as the plan for the 1895 building or the City’s capital investments
before acting. He stated that Vietnam veterans are concerned they will not be
alive to see the memorial. He suggested prioritizing the return of the
Vietnam wall and hosting a ceremony, which Councilor Clingan also
expressed support for. Chair Clingan asked Liaison Hutter to the convey to
the Administration that the Committee would like to see this project
prioritized.
RECOMMENDED TO BE MARKED WORK
COMPLETED
RESULT:
4.
By Councilor Clingan and Councilor Ewen-Campen
That the Director of Inspectional Services appear before this Council to
discuss the Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority (MBTA)’s
application to the Mass Architectural Access Board, on behalf of the City of
Somerville, to circumvent Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)
compliance.
Order
(ID # 24-1486)
Director Postlewaite stated that the City does not have jurisdiction over
MBTA to require or to determine for them what is considered accessible. He
said that this is determined by the state through the MAAB and the federal
government through the FTA. He said that when the Gilman Square station
was originally constructed, the MBTA gained a variance for the slopes of the
approach hills leading to the station, which were considered “existing
conditions.” He noted that the slopes of these hills are 7.5% and 9%. He
stated that this is supported by the Massachusetts Access Law, which
Page 2 of 5
Public Utilities and Public Works Committee
Meeting Minutes
December 9, 2024
pre-dates the ADA and provides an exception for public ways on natural
grade that exceeds the 5% maximum slope for a walkway. He stated that the
MBTA went through the correct process to obtain variances and restore
existing conditions to how they were pre-construction. He stated that the
MBTA is getting an additional variance from the MAAB because they could
not meet the initial variance of 7.5%. They went up to an 8.75% slope on the
bridge that goes over the railroad tracks, which is owned by the state and
does not require the City’s approval.
Chair Clingan asked about ADA compliance at the Ball Square station.
Director Postlewaite stated that ADA compliant does not mean ADA
compliant from every direction one could approach the station. He stated
that when the slope of the street exceeds 5% it is considered non-ADA
compliant and that there is a grace area of up to 8% because that is the
maximum slope for a wheelchair ramp. Councilor McLaughlin stated that
the Gilman station is technically ADA accessible, but not practically
accessible. He noted that improvements are coming. Chair Clingan asked for
an accessibility evaluation of all the stations in Somerville and Director
Postlewaite stated that he will get started on this.
RECOMMENDED TO BE MARKED WORK
COMPLETED
RESULT:
5.
By Councilor Clingan
That the Commissioner of Public Works repair the streetlights along Mystic
Avenue between the Medford line and Temple Street.
Order
(ID # 24-1481)
Chair Clingan stated that the City technically owns the portion of the
streetlights that are out along Mystic Avenue, and that as of December 2nd,
replacement lights have been ordered per the attached memo.
RECOMMENDED TO BE MARKED WORK
COMPLETED
RESULT:
6.
By Councilor Clingan, Councilor Burnley Jr. and Councilor Ewen-Campen
That the Commissioner of Public Works provide this Council with a list of
the elevators in all city buildings, the operational status of each elevator, and
the maintenance and inspection records for each.
Order
(ID # 24-1398)
Two memos were received for this item and are included as attachments.
Chair Clingan stated that per the memo, there are 16 elevators in the city; 9
of the elevators are in schools; and 6 City buildings have elevators. He
shared that concerns were raised regarding elevators throughout the City, so
a status update of all elevators was requested to ensure they are working.
RECOMMENDED TO BE MARKED WORK
COMPLETED
RESULT:
Page 3 of 5
Public Utilities and Public Works Committee
Meeting Minutes
December 9, 2024
7.
By Councilor Wilson and Councilor Scott
That the Administration update this Council on plans for the Cummings
School building and Founders Memorial Skating Rink this fiscal year.
Resolution
(ID # 24-1306)
Chair Clingan provided an overview of the memo that was included with
this item. He stated that the Cummings School building will be the site of a
warming center. Liaison Hutter noted that the warming center at the
Cummings School building is currently in operation, and that it took a
significant amount of work to make it operational. She noted that a portable
company was hired for the bathrooms because the bathrooms in this building
are children sized. She noted that a lot of work went into bringing this
portion of the building up to code, and that there is outstanding work needed
for the remainder of the building that is not yet in use.
Chair Clingan provided an overview of the current plan for the Founders
Memorial Rink according to the attached memo. Per the memo, he stated
that the plan is in its infancy and that the interim plan is to use the space for
recreation activities such as pickleball, noting that there is a heating issue in
the winter. Councilor McLaughlin highlighted the need for a Youth Services
space.
RECOMMENDED TO BE MARKED WORK
COMPLETED
RESULT:
8.
By Councilor Strezo
That the Director of Emergency Management discuss the city’s emergency
response plan for freight train routes and action plans in the event of a
derailment or chemical spill.
Order
(ID # 24-1182)
Councilor Strezo noted that several freight train lines come through
Somerville and that she wants to ensure the City is prepared to respond to
toxic spills from train derailments. She noted that these types of incidents
have occurred elsewhere in the past, including a toxic spill resulting from a
train derailment in Pennsylvania in recent years.
A memo for this item was included as an attachment to the previous
Committee meeting. Director Fisher stated that there appear to be four lines
that are active in Somerville. He provided an overview of the “all hazards
approach” that applies to toxic spills and described the work being done for
emergency management preparation in Somerville through the Emergency
Planning Commission and the Somerville Emergency Management Team.
He stated that the City’s Emergency Management Plan is in the process of
being updated for the first time since 2015 and should be ready by the
beginning of 2025.
Regarding preparedness for toxic spills from freight train derailment,
Director Fisher stated that there are evacuation plans in place and that a key
step is identifying the chemical and the risk associated with that chemical in
order to establish a safe perimeter. He stated that they are working on a
Page 4 of 5
Public Utilities and Public Works Committee
Meeting Minutes
December 9, 2024
notification system that would send alerts to everyone within a particular
geographic region. He also described how Massachusetts is a home rule
state, in which the City can decide whether to request help from the State or
the federal government in emergency situations. He noted that Somerville
also has mutual aid agreements in place that it may utilize in the event of an
emergency situation.
RECOMMENDED TO BE MARKED WORK
COMPLETED
RESULT:
Referenced Documents:
•
PUPW - 2024-12-09 Memo (with 24-1398)
•
PUPW - 2024-12-09 Memo (with 24-1608 and 24-1306)
•
PUPW - 2024-12-09 Memo (with 24-1481 and 24-1398)
Page 5 of 5