Matters ▸ Attachment
Infrastructure BoA Presentation 2017Apr27 reduced — File 203293
Mayor Joseph A. Curtatone
Presented by
Richard E. Raiche, PE, PMP, Director of Engineering
Robert T. King, PE, Director of Capital Projects
Spring 2017
Delivering on SomerVision:
3 key commitments
GLX
Zoning
Infrastructure
2
Infrastructure Information
Part One:
Somerville’s Urban Hydrology
Somerville Geography
4.2 square miles – every square
foot is valuable!
Somerville: Geography 101
Hills, wetlands, and rivers
1852
Fill, Development, and MDC
pipes
Present day
Water flows downhill, and to
MWRA pipes
Elevation
100 to 150 feet
65 to 100 feet
40 to 65 feet
20 to 40 feet
-11 to 20 feet
Urban Hydrology
Where does water go, and why
doesn’t it go there sometimes?
Hydrologic Cycle
Storm drains, sanitary sewers and
combined systems
Somerville’s System
State of the Art water handling…
in 1890
Collection System
502
1305
694
915
18
153
64
1860 to
1880
1880 to
1900
1900 to
1920
1920 to
1940
1940 to
1960
1960 to
1980
1980 to
present
Sewer & Drain Lines Built
Combined sewers
Combined
68 miles
Sanitary
62 miles
Storm Drain
35 miles
* Sanitary & Storm in shared trench
Combined
68 miles
Sanitary
62 miles
Storm Drain
35 miles
* Sanitary & Storm in shared trench
Two pipe roads
… but not really separate
Smaller pipes flow to larger ones
– 3 major interceptors
Beacon-Washington-Somerville
Cambridge Branch
McGrath Somerville Marginal
Tannery Brook
Alewife Brook Conduit
Major Subsystems
Subsystem statistics
19
33
98
76
10-Year Flood Volume
(mgd)
High level estimates of sanitary flow based on 2017 assessors data for bedrooms and building square footage time
typical wastewater generation rates.
High level estimates for flood volume based on 24-hour precipitation, calculated area, imperviousness per EPA source
data and factors for runoff reaching the system.
0.53 1.02
2.67
1.82
Sanitary Flow
(mgd)
Problems
• Why do things go wrong?
311 Reports
• Call types include: sewage, sewer, water inquiries, water issues, water
leak in house, water emergency
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
July
August
September
October
November
December
January
February
March
April
May
June
July
August
September
October
November
December
January
February
2015
2016
2017
311 Water & Sewer Related Calls,* 2015-2017
Heat Map: CY2016 311 W&S Calls
Blockages and Collapses
Maintenance and Repairs
• Blockages can be
cleared
• Collapses require
emergency repairs
Systematic Flooding
• Load exceeds capacity
Flood Hazards
• Twelve events noted
1968 to 2010
• Twelve high risk areas
defined
• Model predicts damages
between $38.5M and
$192.5M
Constraints
• What is out of Somerville’s
control?
Regulatory & Permit Restrictions
Our use is regulated by
permits issued by:
•
MWRA Municipal
Sewer
•
EPA/DEP NPDES CSO
•
EPA/DEP NPDES MS4
Separate
Stormwater
Discharge
Combined
Sewer
Overflows
Sewer
Discharge
Physical limitations
• MWRA interceptors
Union Square – Nexus of Flows
• Uphill / Up-pipe areas all contribute to flooding
60% of
Somerville’s
flow
Cambridge flow
MWRA System
Rain from above.. trouble from below
Past Planning
These aren’t new problems, what
has been done to find solutions?
Millers River Drainage
- Capacity in MBTA System
1990s - present
Sewer Separation
– Cost Prohibitive
CDM Reports 1994 – 2009
• Marginal sewer
separation $74M
2009$
• Tannery Brook
partial sewer
separation $33M
2006$
• Cambridge Branch
partial sewer
separation $115M
plus $?? stormwater
pumping & outfall
2009$
• No projects
resulted
SomerVision
2009 - present
• Increase level of service
• Remove stormwater from system
• Reduce flooding and CSOs
Stormwater Management
MWH Report 2013
• Shifted focus
• Previous solutions
▫Bottom of hill
▫End-of-pipe
▫Increase capacity
• New solutions
▫Intercept rain
▫Distributed
throughout
catchment
▫Preserve capacity
Stormwater Management Strategies
• Runoff management
• Surface storage
• Underground storage
• Pipe capacity
Combined
68 miles
Sanitary
62 miles
Storm Drain
35 miles
* Sanitary & Storm in shared trench
Locally separate stormwater pipes
Project identification and evaluation
• Concept designs – 8 areas / 11 sub-alternatives
• Cost estimates
• Hydraulic modeling
Project ranking
• Flood Reduction
▫What is the total benefit of the project?
• Cost-Effectiveness
▫What is the cost per gallon of benefit?
• Conclusions
▫Lincoln Park is most cost-effective, but has smaller impact
▫Somerville Ave Drain has most impact, but expensive
▫Nunziato most balanced, with high impact and cost-effective
▫Conway half as beneficial at similar cost range
• No other projects provide substantial benefits cost-effectively
System Problems
– Systematic Solutions
Flooding occurs because the
system moves water downhill.
Solutions need to be system-wide.
Complex problem without simple
solution
Requires suite of targeted control
measures
Sewer
separation &
infiltration /
inflow
mitigation
Green
stormwater
infrastructure
Stormwater
storage tanks
New
stormwater
discharges
Ongoing and evolving strategy
• Past – Present – Future
• Large scale and small scale
Beacon St. Tank
Western Somerville Ave Drain
Cedar St.
Sewer Separation
Symphony
Park
Chuckie
Harris
Park
Lincoln
Park
CP2/CP3
Somerville
Ave Drain
GLX
Connection
Nunziato
Tank
Citywide
Development
4:1 I/I
Requirement
Targeted
Separation
Data-driven planning and design
• State of the Art for the
21st Century
Infrastructure Information
Part Two:
Proposed Major Infrastructure
Projects
3 Project Overview
Nunziato Field
Redbridge PS
USQ Infrastructure
Nunziato Field
Stormwater Storage
Green Infrastructure
Field Upgrades
Stormwater Storage Facility
UNDERGROUND
TANK
PUMP
STATION
DIVERSION
STRUCTURE
ADDING
CATCH
BASINS
Tank Excavation
Sewer & Drain Vaults
Park Improvements
Existing Example
Beacon Street (1 MG Storage)
Construction Estimate
Nunziato Field Stormwater Storage and Park
Upgrades
Estimated construction timeframe:
•
27 months of phased construction
•
Storage Tank
•
Diversion Structure
•
Putnam and Vinal Improvements
•
9 months of park work.
•
Field
•
Dog Park
•
Plaza
Estimated construction cost:
•
$14, 600,000 (construction and construction oversight)
USQ - Somerville Ave Sewer Separation
and Streetscapes Restoration
Box Culvert and Utilities – Cross-Section
New 16" Water Main
Line Existing 39" by 26"
Brick Sanitary Sewer
New 14' by
6' Stormwater Box
Culvert
Line Existing 72" Brick
Combined Sewer
New
Communications
Duct Bank
Existing
Communications,
Electric, and Gas
New 12" Water Main
Line Existing 12" Clay
Sanitary Sewer
Streetscapes – Typical Section
Stormwater Green
Infrastructure
Silva Cells
6.5' Fully Protected
Bike Lanes
11' Travel Lanes
7' Parking Lane
(where space
available)
51 New Trees
Streetscapes
Construction Estimate
Somerville Avenue Sewer Separation and
Streetscape Upgrades
Estimated construction timeframe:
•
3 full construction seasons (3 years if we start in March/April)
•
Anticipated construction includes the infrastructure constructed
from Bow Street to Medford Street with the Streetscape to follow
behind.
Estimated construction cost:
•
$50,350,000 (currently working to finalize estimate)
•
MassWorks as partner will save the City $13,000,000
•
MassWorks has deadlines
Redbridge Pump
Station
Separation Opportunities
Proposed Connection
Construction Estimate
Redbridge Pump Station
Design has not been started (work pending Board approval)
Estimated design timeframe:
•
Secure OPM
•
Secure Architect
•
1 year design.
Estimated construction timeframe:
•
1.5 – 2 years of construction
•
Building / Pump Station / Wetwell
•
Force main connection
Estimated design & construction cost:
•
$19,600,000
Questions?
Mayor Joseph A. Curtatone
Presented by
Richard E. Raiche, PE, PMP, Director of Engineering
Robert T. King, PE, Director of Capital Projects
Spring 2017