DRAFT - Bok Memo - Police Contracts-1 — File 22-0179

Page 1 BRVWRn CiW\ CRXncil Wa\V & MeanV CRmmiWWee Ken]ie BRk, ChaiU PROLFH CRQWUDFWV DV PROLF\ DRFXPHQWV DRAFT MEMO FOR COUNCIL CONSIDERATION CRXQFLORUV BRN, CDPSEHOO, & EGZDUGV ILOHG DRFNHW #0840 LQ JXO\ 2020 IRU WKH SXUSRVHV RI GLVFXVVLQJ SROLF\ SULQFLSOHV WKDW WKH BRVWRQ CLW\ CRXQFLO VKRXOG XSKROG LQ LWV UHYLHZ RI WKH FLW\¶V XSFRPLQJ URXQG RI SROLFH FRQWUDFWV. BHORZ, LQ URXJK GUDIW IRUP E\ WKH CKDLU, DUH VRPH FRUH SULQFLSOHV DQG SRWHQWLDO DSSOLFDWLRQV WKDW HPHUJHG IURP WKH CRXQFLO¶V VFUXWLQ\ RI WKH H[LVWLQJ SROLFH FRQWUDFWV DQG RYHUWLPH EXGJHW. 7KLV PHPR ZDV RULJLQDOO\ VKDUHG ZLWK WKH CRXQFLO RQ NRYHPEHU 30, 2020 DQG LV EHLQJ UHVXEPLWWHG LQ 2021 IRU IXUWKHU FRQVLGHUDWLRQ DQG IHHGEDFN. PULQFLSOHV IRU DLVFXVVLRQ 1. FLVFDO RHVSRQVLELOLW\ DQG FDLUQHVV WR AOO CLW\ WRUNHUV. In Whe cRnWe[W Rf a UeceVViRn ZhRVe imSacWV Rn Whe CiW\¶V Wa[ baVe Zill be felW fRU \eaUV and Whe legal UeTXiUemenW WhaW Whe CiW\ mainWain a balanced bXdgeW, WhiV CRXncil haV a dXW\ WR all BRVWRn UeVidenWV WR aSSURYe Rnl\ fiVcall\ UeVSRnVible cRnWUacWV, and a dXW\ WR ciYilian CiW\ emSlR\eeV WR enVXUe WhaW Whe financial imSacWV Rf WighWeU bXdgeWV be VhaUed faiUl\ acURVV all XniWV. 2. AFFRXQWDELOLW\ IRU UVH RI FRUFH DQG AEXVH RI PRZHU. BRWh Whe WalVh AdminiVWUaWiRn and membeUV Rf WhiV CRXncil aUe SXVhing fRU neZ SRlice accRXnWabiliW\ mechaniVmV: an Office Rf PRlice AccRXnWabiliW\ and TUanVSaUenc\ and/RU an emSRZeUed CiYilian ReYieZ BRaUd. In WhiV cRnWe[W, WhiV CRXncil mXVW inViVW WhaW Whe ne[W URXnd Rf SRlice cRnWUacWV inclXde adeTXaWe SURYiViRnV WR allRZ an\ VXch neZ mechaniVmV WR ZRUk effecWiYel\. 3. CLYLOLDQL]DWLRQ RI CLYLOLDQ WRUN. GiYen e[iVWing VWaffing SUeVVXUeV in UegaUd WR VZRUn RfficeUV, and bURad cRnVenVXV ZiWhin bRWh Whe cRmmXniW\ and Whe SRlice deSaUWmenW WhaW a VignificanW SRUWiRn Rf Whe ZRUk cXUUenWl\ being dRne b\ SRlice ZRXld be beWWeU addUeVVed b\ XnaUmed ciYilianV, VZRUn RfficeUV VhRXld be UeVeUYed fRU WUXe SRlice ZRUk. The CRXncil VhRXld e[SecW WhaW Whe ne[W URXnd Rf SRlice cRnWUacWV Zill allRZ bRWh fRU Whe ciYiliani]aWiRn Rf adminiVWUaWiYe ZRUk cXUUenWl\ SeUfRUmed b\ VZRUn RfficeUV and fRU VRme ciYilian dXWieV WR be mRYed RXW Rf Whe deSaUWmenW enWiUel\. ThiV VhRXld inclXde Whe RSSRUWXniW\ fRU a VXbVWanWial SRUWiRn Rf cRnVWUXcWiRn deWail ZRUk WR be claimed b\ a neZ cRmmXniW\-baVed ciYilian ZRUkfRUce. 4. TUDQVSDUHQF\ WR EQKDQFH DQG EQVXUH PXEOLF TUXVW. In RUdeU WR enVXUe demRcUaWic accRXnWabiliW\ fRU hRZ SRlicing iV cRndXcWed and hRZ SRlice fXndV aUe XVed, and WheUeb\ XndeUSin cRmmXniW\ cRnfidence in Whe SRlice, Whe CRXncil haV an inWeUeVW in demanding WhaW Whe ne[W URXnd Rf SRlice cRnWUacWV enable Whe XniYeUVal ZeaUing Rf bRd\ cameUaV and cRnViVWenW SXblic daWa VhaUing abRXW man\ aVSecWV Rf SRlice deSaUWmenW ZRUk. AOO WKHVH SULQFLSOHV DUH FRQVLVWHQW ZLWK SXEOLF VDIHW\, JRRG SROLFLQJ, DQG JRRG JRYHUQPHQW. TKH CRXQFLO¶V SXEOLF SROLF\ LQWHUHVWV LQ WKH CLW\¶V SROLFH FRQWUDFWV UHIOHFW WKH XQLTXH UROH RI SROLFLQJ DV D IURQWOLQH SXEOLF VHUYLFH HQWUXVWHG ZLWK WKH XVH RI IRUFH, DQG DV D PDMRU SRUWLRQ

Page 2 BRVWRn CiW\ CRXncil Wa\V & MeanV CRmmiWWee Ken]ie BRk, ChaiU RI WKH CLW\ EXGJHW. WH DUH JUDWHIXO IRU LQIRUPDWLYH FRQYHUVDWLRQV ZLWK YDULRXV VWDNHKROGHUV WR GDWH, LQFOXGLQJ ILVFDO DQDO\VWV, FRPPXQLW\ DGYRFDWHV, BPD FRPPDQG VWDII, & WKH SXEOLF. PRVVLEOH ASSOLFDWLRQV RI WKHVH PULQFLSOHV 1. FLVFDO RHVSRQVLELOLW\ DQG FDLUQHVV WR AOO CLW\ WRUNHUV a. E[SHFWDWLRQ 1.1: RHDFK SD\ WHUPV LQ SDULW\ ZLWK FLYLOLDQ ZRUNIRUFH. AV ZaV SRinWed RXW in Whe CiW\ Rf BRVWRn¶V 2013 diVVenW fURm Whe VWaWe-leYel JRinW LabRU-ManagemenW CRmmiWWee deciViRn Rn Whe BPPA cRnWUacW fRU FY11-16 (E[KLELW A, S. 12), WhaW majRU deciViRn gaYe SRlice a 25.4% UaiVe RYeU Vi[ \eaUV Zhile Whe ciYilian ZRUkfRUce Rnl\ VaZ a 12.3% incUeaVe RYeU Whe Vame SeUiRd. ThiV gaS haV Vince Zidened VWill fXUWheU; in Whe mRVW UecenW VeW Rf cRnWUacWV, SRlice aSSeaUed WR UeceiYe Whe Vame annXal 2% incUeaVe aV RWheU baUgaining XniWV, bXW in facW UeceiYed a VignificanW addiWiRnal bXmS in Whe fRUm Rf a ha]aUd Sa\ incUeaVe, Zhich iV cRXnWed aV UegXlaU cRmSenVaWiRn fRU all UeleYanW SXUSRVeV (E[KLELW B). AV Whe CRXncil VWaWed in a XnanimRXV 2016 leWWeU (E[KLELW C), ³Ze aUe deeSl\ cRnceUned b\ Whe Zidening Sa\ diVSaUiW\ beWZeen SXblic VafeW\ XniRnV and RXU ciYilian ciW\ emSlR\eeV,´ and ³eVcalaWing SXblic VafeW\ ValaUieV haYe VTXee]ed RXW RWheU CiW\ SRViWiRnV.´ The CRXncil iV WheUefRUe Xnlikel\ WR aSSURYe fXUWheU aUbiWUaWiRn aZaUdV WhaW e[aceUbaWe WhiV d\namic. TKH CRXQFLO H[SHFWV WKDW WKH QHZ URXQG RI SROLFH FRQWUDFWV ZLOO QDUURZ WKLV GLVSDULW\ ZLWK FLYLOLDQ SD\, QRW ZLGHQ LW. b. E[SHFWDWLRQ 1.2: RHIRUP VWUXFWXUHV WKDW WUHDW RYHUWLPH DV D URXWLQH PHDVXUH. The cRVW Rf SRlice RYeUWime WR Whe CiW\ haV ballRRned enRUmRXVl\ RYeU Whe SaVW decade; aV VhRZn b\ Whe BM5B¶V JXl\ 2020 UeSRUW (E[KLELW D), iW haV incUeaVed fURm aSSUR[imaWel\ $40 milliRn in 2010 WR $72.5 milliRn in 2020, an 81% incUeaVe. ThiV iV IRXU WLPHV Whe UaWe Rf inflaWiRn, Zhich iV XS Rnl\ 19% RYeU Whe Vame decade. A nXmbeU Rf SURYiViRnV Rf Whe cRnWUacW aSSeaU deVigned WR ma[imi]e RYeUWime, inclXding a SURYiViRn (AUWicle IX, SecWiRn 3.D) UeTXiUing WhaW VhifWV nRW be UeaUUanged WR UedXce RYeUWime RSSRUWXniWieV (E[KLELW E, S. 20). B\ cRnWUaVW, if RfficeUV ZhR URXWinel\ aWWend cRXUW ZeUe Rn UegXlaU dXW\ fRU aW leaVW VRme hRXUV Zhen cRXUWV nRUmall\ RSeUaWe, RU RfficeUV URXWinel\ aWWending cRmmXniW\ eYenWV ZeUe Rn UegXlaU dXW\ Rn Zeekda\ eYeningV, RfficeUV¶ legiWimaWe deViUe fRU SUedicWable hRXUV cRXld be haUmRni]ed ZiWh Whe SXblic fidXciaU\ inWeUeVW in minimi]ing RYeUWime. TKH CRXQFLO H[SHFWV WKDW QHZ SROLFH FRQWUDFWV VKRXOG VHHN WR FRQYHUW VXFK URXWLQH XVHV RI RYHUWLPH LQWR UHJXODU KRXUV, WKHUHE\ UHVHUYLQJ RYHUWLPH IRU JHQXLQHO\ XQSUHGLFWDEOH DVSHFWV RI SXEOLF VDIHW\ ZRUN. F. E[SHFWDWLRQ 1.3: EQDEOH RYHUDOO RYHUWLPH DQG GHSDUWPHQW EXGJHW UHGXFWLRQV. In lighW Rf Whe afRUemenWiRned UeceVViRn, alRng ZiWh RngRing eYalXaWiRnV aV WR Zhich WaVkV cXUUenWl\ aVVigned WR Whe SRlice deSaUWmenW cRXld be mRUe aSSURSUiaWel\ handled b\ ciYilian RU VeUYice-SURYideU SaUWneUV, Whe CiW\ UeTXiUeV Whe fle[ibiliW\ WR make aSSURSUiaWe SXblic VafeW\ bXdgeWing deciViRnV in Whe cRming \eaU. TheVe cRXld inclXde an RYeUall UedXcWiRn in Whe SRlice bXdgeW in RUdeU WR enable RWheU SXblic-VafeW\-UelaWed UeinYeVWmenWV. TKH CRXQFLO H[SHFWV WKDW WKH QHZ SROLFH FRQWUDFWV ZLOO UHFRJQL]H WKH QHHG WR DFKLHYH ILQDQFLDO HIILFLHQFLHV, DQG WKHUHIRUH PDNH DPHQGPHQWV WR WLJKWHQ

Page 3 BRVWRn CiW\ CRXncil Wa\V & MeanV CRmmiWWee Ken]ie BRk, ChaiU RYHUWLPH DQG RWKHU SURYLVLRQV VXFK DV ZRXOG KDYH VDYHG WKH CLW\ DW OHDVW $40 PLOOLRQ LI DSSOLHG LQ FY20. d. E[SHFWDWLRQ 1.4: TLJKWHQ RYHUVLJKW RQ LQMXUHG-GXW\ OLVW. AUWicle XIII Rf Whe BPPA cRnWUacW (E[KLELW E, S. 31) la\V RXW Whe SaUameWeUV b\ Zhich a BPD RfficeU iV Slaced and UeWained Rn injXUed dXW\; VXUSUiVingl\, a SURYiViRn Rf WhaW aUWicle cXUUenWl\ allRZV VRme SaUWial-dXW\ RfficeUV WR cRnWinXe WR VeUYe Said deWailV. AV VhRZn b\ daWa SURYided b\ Whe BRVWRn PRlice DeSaUWmenW Rn NRYembeU 16, 2020 (E[KLELW F, S. 7), Whe nXmbeU Rf RfficeUV Rn lRng-WeUm injXUed RU illneVV VWaWXV ZaV VWable fRU FY17-19, incUeaVing Rnl\ VlighWl\ fURm 146 in Jan¶17 WR 151 in Jan¶18 WR 158 RfficeUV in Jan¶19. ThiV nXmbeU When URVe dUamaWicall\ aV Rf JanXaU\ 2020 WR 216 RfficeUV, and iW VWandV aV Rf SeSWembeU 2020 aW 270 RfficeUV, RU abRXW a WenWh Rf Whe WRWal fRUce. ThiV UeSUeVenWV a 71% incUeaVe RYeU 21 mRnWhV, an XSWick WhaW SUedaWeV Whe RnVeW Rf COVID-19. JXVW Whe cRVW Rf UeSlacing WheVe addiWiRnal 112 RfficeUV (158 YV. 270) likel\ amRXnWV WR $17.5 milliRn RU mRUe in RYeUWime cRVWV. IW iV imSeUaWiYe bRWh fiVcall\ and fRU Whe healWh Rf Whe CiW\¶V SRlice RfficeUV WhaW Whe deSaUWmenW UeYeUVe WhiV UecenW alaUming WUend, aV Ze knRZ iW iV endeaYRUing WR dR. TKH CRXQFLO H[SHFWV WKDW QHZ SROLFH FRQWUDFWV ZLOO DLP WR FXUE WKLV GUDPDWLF LQFUHDVH LQ RIILFHUV RQ LQMXUHG GXW\, ZKHWKHU WKURXJK PRGLILFDWLRQ RI AUWLFOH XIII, QHZ LQMXU\ ULVN PLWLJDWLRQ SURWRFROV, RU RWKHU VWHSV. 2. AFFRXQWDELOLW\ IRU UVH RI FRUFH DQG AEXVH RI PRZHU a. E[SHFWDWLRQ 2.1: RHPRYH ELQGLQJ DUELWUDWLRQ IRU PDMRU GLVFLSOLQH DQG HQDEOH QHZ DFFRXQWDELOLW\ PHDVXUHV WR RSHUDWH HIIHFWLYHO\. AUWicle VI Rf Whe 2007 BPPA cRnWUacW, enWiWled ³GUieYance & ASSeal´ (E[KLELW E, S. 7), iV Whe mechaniVm WhaW dUiYeV almRVW all labRU-managemenW diVSXWeV in Whe SRlice deSaUWmenW WR binding aUbiWUaWiRn. AUbiWUaWRUV haYe RYeUWXUned neaUl\ WhUee-TXaUWeUV Rf BPD diVciSline and neaUl\ a WhiUd Rf fiUingV RYeU Whe SaVW 13 \eaUV, SeU CDPSDLJQ =HUR (E[KLELW G, SS. 6-7). The 1979 BPPA cRnWUacW SUeYiRXVl\ e[emSWed deciViRnV UegaUding VXVSenViRn and diVchaUge fURm binding aUbiWUaWiRn, bXW Whe 2007 cRnWUacW UemRYed WhaW e[emSWiRn (E[KLELW H, S. 5). FRU Whe UecRmmendaWiRnV Rf an emSRZeUed CiYilian ReYieZ BRaUd²ZheWheU aV SURSRVed b\ Whe Ma\RU (E[KLELW I) RU b\ ceUWain CRXncilRUV (E[KLELW J)²WR nRW Rnl\ be acWed XSRn b\ Whe PRlice CRmmiVViRneU bXW acWXall\ XSheld, WKH CRXQFLO H[SHFWV WKDW QHZ FRQWUDFWV ZLOO HLWKHU H[HPSW GLVFLSOLQH DQG GLVFKDUJH IURP ELQGLQJ DUELWUDWLRQ, RU DW PLQLPXP DOORZ WKH UHFRPPHQGDWLRQ RI D GXO\-FRQVWLWXWHG CLYLOLDQ RHYLHZ BRDUG WR VXSHUVHGH WKH MXGJPHQW RI DQ DUELWUDWRU. 3. CLYLOLDQL]DWLRQ RI CLYLOLDQ WRUN a. E[SHFWDWLRQ 3.1: CLYLOLDQL]H DGPLQLVWUDWLYH UROHV ZLWKLQ WKH GHSDUWPHQW. In iWV JXl\ 28, 2020 SUeVenWaWiRn WR Whe CRXncil, BPD made UefeUence WR a lRng-WeUm gRal Rf ciYiliani]ing 80 WR 100 adminiVWUaWiYe SRViWiRnV cXUUenWl\ filled b\ VZRUn RfficeUV, ZhR aUe Said aW UegXlaU and ha]aUd Sa\ UaWeV cRmmenVXUaWe ZiWh WheiU WUaining fRU SRlice ZRUk (E[KLELW K, S. 5). GiYen WhaW Whe deSaUWmenW back-fillV abRXW 94 SRlice VhifWV each da\, dUiYing high UeSlacemenW RYeUWime cRVWV, iW ZRXld be adYanWageRXV WR UeWXUn mRUe Rf WheVe VZRUn RfficeUV WR diUecW SRlice ZRUk. Of Whe adminiVWUaWiYe SRViWiRnV cXUUenWl\ RccXSied b\ VZRUn RfficeUV, 32 aUe inYRlYed in RSeUaWing a decenWUali]ed deWail V\VWem

Page 4 BRVWRn CiW\ CRXncil Wa\V & MeanV CRmmiWWee Ken]ie BRk, ChaiU (E[KLELW F, S. 8) Zhich haV been menWiRned fRU UefRUm Vince aW leaVW Whe 1993 cRnWUacW (E[KLELW E, S. 29), and Zhich cXUUenWl\ cRVWV Whe deSaUWmenW mRUe Whan Whe 10% adminiVWUaWiYe feeV WhaW iW UeceiYeV. A nXmbeU Rf deWail V\VWem URleV and RWheU deVk jRbV aUe VSecificall\ deVignaWed fRU VZRUn RfficeUV in Whe BPPA cRnWUacW. TKH CRXQFLO H[SHFWV WKDW QHZ FRQWUDFWV ZLOO SURYLGH WKH PROLFH CRPPLVVLRQHU ZLWK WKH QHFHVVDU\ GLVFUHWLRQ WR FLYLOLDQL]H VXFK UROHV ZKHUH DSSURSULDWH. b. E[SHFWDWLRQ 3.2: OSHQ XS FRQVWUXFWLRQ GHWDLO RSSRUWXQLWLHV WR D ORFDO FLYLOLDQ ZRUNIRUFH. The BRVWRn PRlice DeSaUWmenW UeSRUWV WhaW RYeU Whe laVW Wen mRnWhV, 26,410 deWailV haYe gRne XnaVVigned/Xnclaimed, cRmSaUed WR 23,856 deWailV claimed b\ RfficeUV RYeU Whe Vame SeUiRd (E[KLELW F, S. 8). A laUge SURSRUWiRn Rf WheVe deWailV, claimed and Xnclaimed, aUe cRnVWUXcWiRn deWailV WhURXghRXW Whe ciW\. WiWh ZageV Said mainl\ b\ deYelRSeUV and XWiliW\ cRmSanieV, aVVigning a SRUWiRn Rf WheVe deWailV WR ciYilian flaggeUV cRXld UeSUeVenW an e[ciWing RSSRUWXniW\ WR cUeaWe gRRd neZ jRbV fRU BRVWRn UeVidenWV, eVSeciall\ Whe UeVidenWV Rf cRlRU diVSURSRUWiRnaWel\ imSacWed b\ XnemSlR\menW, lRng-Wime ecRnRmic ineTXiWieV, and Whe cXUUenW UeceVViRn, aV FDPLOLHV IRU JXVWLFH DV HHDOLQJ haV SRinWed RXW (E[KLELW L). FXUWheUmRUe, Whe 10% in adminiVWUaWiYe feeV fRU Whe deWailV cXUUenWl\ gRing Xnclaimed cRXld definiWel\ cRYeU Whe adminiVWUaWiYe cRVWV fRU VXch a ciYilian emSlR\menW effRUW. TKH CRXQFLO H[SHFWV QHZ FRQWUDFWV WR HQDEOH WKH PROLFH CRPPLVVLRQHU WR DVVLJQ VRPH SRUWLRQ RI WKHVH FRQVWUXFWLRQ GHWDLOV WR EH ILOOHG RXWVLGH WKH PROLFH DHSDUWPHQW. c. E[SHFWDWLRQ 3.3: EQVXUH WKDW ODWLWXGH H[LVWV WR FUHDWH XQDUPHG FLYLOLDQ HQWLWLHV WR UHVSRQG WR VRPH 911 FDOOV. CRXncilRUV haYe UaiVed Whe SRVVibiliW\ Rf eVWabliVhing an alWeUnaWiYe 911 emeUgenc\ UeVSRnVe (E[KLELW M), and Whe BRVWRn PRlice RefRUm TaVk FRUce inclXded in iWV final UeSRUW (E[KLELW N) Whe UecRmmendaWiRn WhaW ³Whe CiW\ VhRXld idenWif\, VWUengWhen, and e[Sand VeUYiceV WhaW aSSURSUiaWel\ VeUYe and VXSSRUW Whe BPD in VhifWing UeVSRnVibiliW\ in UeVSRnding WR inVWanceV inYRlYing SeRSle e[SeUiencing hRmeleVVneVV, VXbVWance XVe, menWal healWh cUiVeV, RU RWheU VRcial YXlneUabiliWieV.´ A laUge nXmbeU Rf BPD RfficeUV aUe alUead\ ZRUking in SaUWneUVhiS ZiWh VeUYice-SURYideUV aURXnd VXch iVVXeV, and BPD leadeUVhiS haV UeSRUWed acWiYel\ lRRking aW mRdelV WhaW ZRXld allRZ fRU fRUmall\ eVWabliVhing VXch alWeUnaWiYe UeVSRnVe mechaniVmV. In Whe SaVW, hRZeYeU, effRUWV WR cUeaWe alWeUnaWiYe SXblic VafeW\ UeVSRnVe mRdelV ± fURm MaWWaSan ciYilian SaWURlV in Whe 1970V, WR Whe eVWabliVhmenW Rf Whe DRZnWRZn BXVineVV ImSURYemenW DiVWUicW in Whe 1990V, WR mXniciSal SRlice VXSSlemenWing SXblic hRXVing VecXUiW\ in Whe 2000V ± haYe fRXndeUed Rn TXeVWiRnV Rf cRmSaWibiliW\ ZiWh Whe CiW\¶V SRlice cRnWUacWV (E[KLELW H, S. 11). AV Whe CiW\ cRnWinXeV WR e[SlRUe VXch alWeUnaWiYe mRdelV, WKH CRXQFLO H[SHFWV QHZ SROLFH FRQWUDFWV WR EH ZULWWHQ VR DV WR DOORZ IRU WKH FUHDWLRQ RI VXFK DOWHUQDWLYH UHVSRQVH IUDPHZRUNV RXWVLGH RI WKH SROLFH GHSDUWPHQW. 4. TUDQVSDUHQF\ WR EQKDQFH DQG EQVXUH PXEOLF TUXVW a. E[SHFWDWLRQ 4.1: UQLYHUVDOL]H ERG\ FDPHUDV. In Whe inWeUeVW Rf WUanVSaUenc\ and fRU Whe SURWecWiRn Rf bRWh SRlice RfficeUV and RWheU BRVWRn UeVidenWV, bRd\ cameUaV VhRXld be e[Wended WR all BPD XniWV and VhRXld be UeTXiUed WR be ZRUn dXUing RYeUWime hRXUV,

Page 5 BRVWRn CiW\ CRXncil Wa\V & MeanV CRmmiWWee Ken]ie BRk, ChaiU aV called fRU b\ Whe BRVWRn PRlice RefRUm TaVk FRUce (E[KLELW N). In JanXaU\ 2017, a SURYiViRn (AUWicle XVI, SecWiRn 25) ZaV added WR Whe cRnWUacW allRZing fRU baUgaining WR e[Wend RU e[Sand WhiV SURgUam (E[KLELW 2); WKH CRXQFLO H[SHFWV WKDW D IXOO H[SDQVLRQ ZLOO EH DFKLHYHG, ZKHWKHU WKURXJK GHSDUWPHQW SROLF\ RU FRQWUDFW FKDQJH DV QHFHVVDU\. b. E[SHFWDWLRQ 4.2: SKDUH DOO LQIRUPDWLRQ SURYLGHG WR WKH XQLRQV ZLWK WKH SXEOLF DV ZHOO. AW YaUiRXV SRinWV, RXU SRlice cRnWUacWV UeTXiUe WhaW infRUmaWiRn like ZRUk VchedXleV, VhifW YacancieV, aYailable RYeUWime RU deWail VhifWV, VeniRUiW\ liVWV, RUdeUV, eWc. be SXblicl\ SRVWed Rn deSaUWmenW bXlleWin bRaUdV RU RWheUZiVe VhaUed ZiWh Whe XniRnV. ThiV infRUmaWiRn VhRXld be SXblicl\ SRVWed and VhaUed ZiWh Whe SXblic aV Zell, eVSeciall\ giYen Whe UecenW lack Rf claUiW\ abRXW minimXm VWaffing leYelV. TKH CRXQFLO H[SHFWV LQFUHDVHG WUDQVSDUHQF\ DERXW KRZ WKH SROLFH IRUFH LV W\SLFDOO\ GLVWULEXWHG DFURVV WKH CLW\, DQG WR ZKDW H[WHQW WKLV GLVWULEXWLRQ LV GLFWDWHG E\ FRQWUDFWV RU DW PROLFH CRPPLVVLRQHU GLVFUHWLRQ. c. E[SHFWDWLRQ 2.2 EQVXUH WKDW FRQWUDFW ODQJXDJH GRHV QRW LPSHGH WKH VKDULQJ RI LPSRUWDQW XVH-RI-IRUFH DQG ³VHQVLWLYH RIILFHU FRQGXFW´ DFFRXQWDELOLW\ GDWD ZLWK WKH SXEOLF. The BRVWRn PRlice RefRUm TaVk FRUce¶V UecRmmendaWiRnV #4 and #5 (E[KLELW N) fRcXV Rn Whe cUeaWiRn Rf SXblic-facing daWa daVhbRaUdV in UegaUd WR XVe Rf fRUce, FIOV, cRmSlainWV, VeaUch ZaUUanWV, eWc., WR be diVaggUegaWed b\ caWegRUieV VXch aV Uace, eWhniciW\, and ]iS-cRde. TKH CRXQFLO H[SHFWV WKDW QHZ SROLFH FRQWUDFWV ZLOO QRW LQFOXGH DQ\ SURYLVLRQV WKDW ZRXOG EORFN WKLV LPSRUWDQW SURSRVHG VWHS WR HQKDQFH SXEOLF FRQILGHQFH. LLVW RI E[KLELWV A-O E[hibiW A: BPPA JLMC AZaUd & CiW\ DiVVenW fRU 2010-2016 E[hibiW B: BPPA AgUeemenW fRU 2016-2019 E[hibiW C: BRVWRn CiW\ CRXncil, UnanimRXV LeWWeU Rf FebUXaU\ 24, 2016 E[hibiW D: BMRB ReVeaUch USdaWe fRU JXl\ 2020: BRVWRn PRlice BXdgeW in CRnWe[W E[hibiW E: BPPA CRnWUacW fRU 2007-2010 (NRWH: 7KLV UHPDLQV WKH EDVH FRQWUDFW. 7KH B33A FRQWUDFW UHIHUHQFHG KHUH LV DOVR LOOXVWUDWLYH RI WKH RWKHU XQLW FRQWUDFWV, ZKLFK PRYH LQ WDQGHP.) E[hibiW F: BRVWRn PRlice DeSaUWmenW, CiW\ CRXncil PUeVenWaWiRn fRU NRYembeU 16, 2020 E[hibiW G: CamSaign ZeUR, BRVWRn CiW\ CRXncil PUeVenWaWiRn fRU SeSWembeU 8, 2020 E[hibiW H: CRXncilRU BRk, BRVWRn CiW\ CRXncil PUeVenWaWiRn fRU SeSWembeU 8, 2020 E[hibiW I: Ma\RU WalVh, OUdinance fRU Office Rf PRlice AccRXnWabiliW\ & TUanVSaUenc\ E[hibiW J: CRXncilRUV CamSbell, AUUR\R, & Mejia, OUdinance fRU CiYilian ReYieZ BRaUd E[hibiW K: BRVWRn PRlice DeSaUWmenW, CiW\ CRXncil PUeVenWaWiRn fRU JXl\ 28, 2020 E[hibiW L: FamilieV fRU JXVWice aV Healing ReSRUW: InYeVW in CRmmXniW\ NRW PRlicing E[hibiW M: CRXncilRUV WX, EdZaUdV, & Mejia, OUdinance fRU UnaUmed CiYilian ReVSRnVe E[hibiW N: BRVWRn PRlice RefRUm TaVk FRUce, RecRmmendaWiRnV WR Whe Ma\RU E[hibiW O: BPPA AgUeemenW fRU 2016-2017 AOO H[KLELWV DUH KRVWHG IRU GRZQORDG KHUH.

Page 6 BRVWRn CiW\ CRXncil Wa\V & MeanV CRmmiWWee Ken]ie BRk, ChaiU As Ways & Means Chair, Councilor Bok will welcome feedback on the above principles and related expectations from Councilors, stakeholders, and the public over coming sessions. ASSHQGL[: OWKHU PROLF\ SXJJHVWLRQV E\ AGYRFDWHV & CRXQFLORUV LQ RHFHQW DLVFXVVLRQV 5HFRUGHG KHUH IRU SRVVLEOH IXUWKHU FRQYHUVDWLRQ 1. CUeaWe mechaniVmV WR enable Whe hiUing and SURmRWiRn Rf a mRUe diYeUVe fRUce; WhiV mainl\ UeTXiUeV CiYil SeUYice UefRUmV aW Whe VWaWe leYel. 2. CRnYeUW cRXUW RYeUWime UecRUdV WR an elecWURnic V\VWem, WR beWWeU caWch SRWenWial abXVe, and ZRUk ZiWh Whe DiVWUicW AWWRUne\¶V Rffice WR UedXce RccaViRnV fRU cRXUW RYeUWime, eVSeciall\ aV mRUe Whan half Rf Said cRXUW RYeUWime laVW \eaU ZaV fRU hRXUV XnZRUked (E[KLELW 3). 3. E[SlRUe Za\V WR make Whe VZaSSing Rf WRXUV fRU mXWXal cRnYenience mRUe cRmmRn Whan abVenceV WhaW UeVXlW in RYeUWime. 4. E[SeUimenW ZiWh alWeUnaWiYe VhifW mRdelV WhaW cRXld beWWeU maWch Whe Uh\Whm Rf Whe ZRUk and UeVXlW in leVV RYeUWime. 5. LRZeU Whe Zeekl\ ma[imXm Rf 90 hRXUV ZRUked, dXe WR VafeW\ cRnceUnV fRU bRWh RfficeUV and ciW\ UeVidenWV. 6. RecRnVideU Whe SURYiViRn WhaW aSSlieV Whe BRVWRn UeVidenc\ UeTXiUemenW WR BPD RfficeUV Rnl\ fRU WheiU fiUVW Wen \eaUV Rf VeUYice. 7. Call fRU RSen SRlice cRnWUacW negRWiaWiRnV, Whe inclXViRn Rf cRmmXniW\ RbVeUYeUV, Whe nRWicing Rf cRnWUacW meeWingV, and/RU SXblic UeSRUWV Rn majRU WRSicV aW iVVXe. 8. HRld Whe PRlice DeSaUWmenW WR mXniciSal RUdinance 6-1.12.b (E[KLELW 4), WhaW nR ciW\ emSlR\ee ma\ eaUn mRUe Whan 10% Rf WheiU UegXlaU ValaU\ in RYeUWime ZiWhRXW e[SUeVV aXWhRUi]aWiRn b\ Whe Ma\RU and CiW\ CRXncil. The CiW\¶V CRUSRUaWiRn CRXnVel WakeV Whe SRViWiRn WhaW WhiV RUdinance iV VXSeUVeded b\ Whe CiW\¶V cRllecWiYe baUgaining agUeemenWV and Whe FaiU LabRU SWandaUdV AcW, giYen Whe SRlice deSaUWmenW¶V aVVignmenW Rf VhifWV be\Rnd VXch a limiW (E[KLELW 5). 9. ASSl\ mRUe naUURZl\ Whe CiW\ ChaUWeU langXage in SecWiRn 42 (E[KLELW 6) b\ UeTXiUing Whe PRlice CRmmiVViRneU WR make a VSecific and SXblic declaUaWiRn Rf a ³caVe Rf e[WUeme emeUgenc\ inYRlYing Whe healWh RU VafeW\ Rf Whe SeRSle RU WheiU SURSeUW\´ WhaW jXVWifieV VSending RYeU Whe SRlice deSaUWmenW¶V bXdgeW limiW, UaWheU Whan WUeaWing all SRlice RYeUWime aV aXWRmaWicall\ meeWing WhiV VWandaUd. LLVW RI E[KLELWV P-S E[hibiW P: CRXncilRU AUUR\R, ACLU, PURg. MA, BU SSaUk! Lab ± CRXUW OYeUWime ReSRUW E[hibiW Q: OUdinance EVWabliVhing SWandaUd PURYiViRnV fRU AnnXal ASSURSUiaWe OUdeUV, 1980

Page 7 BRVWRn CiW\ CRXncil Wa\V & MeanV CRmmiWWee Ken]ie BRk, ChaiU E[hibiW R: Gene O¶FlaheUW\, CRUSRUaWiRn CRXnVel, CRUUeVSRndence ZiWh CRXncilRU BRk E[hibiW S: BRVWRn CiW\ ChaUWeU, ed. 2007 AOO H[KLELWV DUH KRVWHG IRU GRZQORDG KHUH.